Background
Social anxiety disorder (SAD) involves experiencing excessive and irrational fear in social settings when performing and being evaluated by others or meeting new people [
1]. This intense emotional experience has a detrimental impact on an individual’s daily functioning and fails to reflect the reality of a situation. In Saudi Arabia, SAD is one of the most prevalent psychological disorders, affecting 5.6% of a sample of 4,004 individuals aged between 15 and 65 [
2].
SAD is influenced by a variety of factors, including biological, psychological, and environmental factors such as peer relationships and parenting [
3]. In recent years, research has increasingly focused on understanding the role of family practices, such as parenting styles, in the development of psychiatric disorders, including SAD [
4]. Parents’ behaviors and attitudes strongly influence the development of their children’s thoughts, behaviors, and personalities [
5]. Parenting styles comprise the emotions, attitudes, and behaviors of parents toward their children [
6]. Baumrind identified three major parenting styles: authoritative, authoritarian, and permissive [
5]. Each parenting style has its unique attributes and effects on the psychological well-being of children. Authoritative parenting involves providing encouragement, support, and a moderate level of control to their children [
5]. Authoritative parents exhibit affection and responsiveness toward their children while maintaining clear expectations and firm boundaries that their children can adhere to [
5]. Children reared in this manner often exhibit higher self-esteem and curiosity than other children [
5]. By contrast, authoritarian parents exercise substantial control over their children, enforce strict regulations, and provide fewer opportunities to them [
5]. Children of authoritarian parents are expected to comply with their parents’ directions without negotiating, which restricts their capacity to grow and cultivate autonomy [
5]. Consequently, they become susceptible to developing low self-esteem, social isolation, and negative thinking patterns [
5]. Finally, permissive parents are non-controlling and highly responsive to their children [
5]. However, they fail to provide structure or guidance for their children. Children of permissive parents tend to make their own decisions independently, without seeking their parents’ assistance or approval [
5]. Consequently, they may experience emotional instability and struggle with self-regulation [
5].
Given the impact of parenting styles on psychological health, research has established a relationship between parenting styles and psychiatric disorders, including SAD. In Saudi Arabia, one study demonstrated the negative impact of authoritarian parenting on the development of SAD in adolescents [
7]. Several studies conducted worldwide have shown that authoritative parenting has a favorable impact on the psychological well-being of children, whereas authoritarian parenting does not [
8,
9]. The adverse effects of parental practices on children may persist well into their old age. Evidence has shown that authoritarian parenting increases the likelihood of anxiety and depression among adults and older adults, whereas authoritative parenting is associated with positive outcomes [
10,
11].
While parenting styles influence psychological health, their effect is particularly important for nursing students. Nursing students are exposed to high-stress environments because of the various academic and clinical challenges they face [
12]. This stress may be particularly intense in students with SAD. These challenges include struggling with class participation, group projects, language requirements, and interpersonal relationships with peers and instructors, and a fear of receiving low grades [
12,
13]. In clinical practice, nursing students may also experience a lack of experience, discomfort from being observed by others, fear of making mistakes and causing harm to patients, exposure to patients dying or suffering, and unfamiliarity with the clinical environment [
12,
14]. Cultural and familial expectations may add to the challenges faced by nursing students. In Saudi Arabia, these expectations may include the public’s lack of awareness of the nursing profession and the perception of it as stressful, leading to the profession of nursing being considered unfavorable in society [
15]. This public perception of the nursing profession could affect nursing students’ mental health and lead to increased feelings of social anxiety. Family life is also important in Saudi culture [
15]. Nursing students may feel pressured to fulfill their family responsibilities while maintaining good academic performance. This can be even more challenging for those raised by authoritarian parents, as they struggle to meet their parents’ expectations and often seek their validation [
5]. To alleviate the impact of these factors, nursing institutions must develop programs and strategies to help students, especially those with SAD, cope with these challenges.
Most related research conducted in Saudi Arabia has focused on investigating the occurrence of and factors related to SAD among undergraduate students. Evidence estimates that 16.3–52% of undergraduate students have SAD [
16‐
19]. Among Saudi nursing students, a study showed that 39.8% had symptoms of SAD [
20]. Furthermore, factors related to SAD among undergraduate students in Saudi Arabia included younger age, female sex, low income, marital status, parental conflict, birth order, grade point average (GPA), and academic year [
16‐
18]. Studies conducted in Ethiopia, Taiwan, and India found that the prevalence of SAD among undergraduate students ranged from 11.3 to 31.2% [
21‐
23].
Even though SAD is prevalent among students in Saudi Arabia, studies did not address the influence of parenting styles on the development of SAD among nursing students. Therefore, this study aimed to assess the prevalence of SAD among nursing students and examine its association with various parenting styles.
Discussion
This study assessed the association between SAD and parenting styles among nursing students at the College of Nursing at KSAU-HS in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. To the best of the author’s knowledge, no such study has been conducted with nursing students in Saudi Arabia. Therefore, this study contributes to the current literature on the potential variables affecting nursing students’ psychological well-being in Saudi Arabia. The findings demonstrated that 47.5% of the nursing students had symptoms of SAD. This finding is consistent with those of other studies conducted with medical students in Saudi Arabia [
16,
17]. For example, a cross-sectional study of 5,896 medical students found significant levels of SAD among participants (51%) [
16]. The prevalence in this study was also higher than the reported prevalence of 39.8 in a sample of 138 nursing students in Saudi Arabia [
20]. Similarly, this study found a higher prevalence of social anxiety than that identified in two previous studies with students enrolled in different programs in Saudi Arabia [
18,
19]. Moreover, the present study found a greater prevalence of SAD than in Ethiopia (31.2%), Taiwan (23.7%), and India (11.3%) [
21‐
23]. The increased prevalence of SAD among female nursing students could be explained by sex differences in vulnerability to anxiety. Females are more biologically and psychologically vulnerable to developing anxiety than males [
16]. It could also be attributed to the variations in academic programs and the stressors encountered by students during their education. The nursing program is rigorous, and its clinical components are more stressful than those of other programs [
12]. Moreover, cultural differences could provide a potential explanation for the variations between this study and those conducted in other countries. A practical explanation for our findings could be a lack of public awareness of the nursing profession coupled with the perception of the nursing profession having unfavorable work conditions [
15].
Most students reported having authoritative parents, followed by authoritarian parents, and few students reported having permissive parents. These findings are inconsistent with previous studies [
28,
29]. For instance, a recent study with Qatari parents revealed that permissive parenting was the most frequently used parenting style among participants, whereas authoritarian parenting was the least used [
29]. This variation in the reported parenting styles could be related to the differences in measurement tools and sample characteristics.
This study revealed that paternal authoritarian parenting was significantly associated with an increased likelihood of experiencing SAD symptoms among nursing students. This was an expected finding because authoritarian parents are more rigorous, critical, overly protective, and concerned with imposing high expectations and moral standards on their children [
5]. Students raised in such a way may develop SAD and negative thoughts and feelings about their competence, impeding their professional growth. This could pose difficulties for them in clinical training as nurses are expected to make quick and effective decisions [
12]. Furthermore, nurses and students with poor self-esteem may struggle to deal with stress and eventually engage in maladaptive coping strategies that further exacerbate their stress [
30]. These findings emphasize the importance of implementing mental health interventions to optimize students’ learning experiences and psychological well-being. Furthermore, they support the need for programs for parents to cultivate positive parenting practices and create a supportive and caring atmosphere that enhances their psychological well-being. This finding is supported by a previous study conducted in Saudi Arabia that found that parental overprotection and criticism are significant risk factors for SAD [
7]. Evidence from other countries has shown that authoritarian parenting results in a high incidence of anxiety among children, whereas authoritative parenting results in better psychological outcomes [
8,
9,
11].
The study found that having an authoritative parent was significantly associated with a decreased likelihood of experiencing SAD among nursing students. Moreover, more than half of the students reported having authoritative parents. Authoritative parents are generally warm and receptive, offer encouragement and support, and foster autonomy in their children [
5]. Such behaviors result in favorable psychological outcomes [
10,
11,
31,
32], as demonstrated in this study. Nursing students raised in authoritative households that promote open communication and self-expression may have higher self-confidence and independence. These characteristics may help students manage the stress associated with academic and clinical training, thereby enhancing their psychological health. This finding aligns with that of a previous study conducted in China that examined 1,345 adolescents and revealed that a parental approach characterized by emotional warmth led to a reduction in SAD among adolescents [
9]. However, post-hoc power analysis revealed small power, and this finding should be interpreted with caution. Accordingly, future studies with larger sample sizes are needed to confirm the association between SAD and authoritative parenting style.
The present study has several limitations that may have affected the overall findings. The use of a cross-sectional design does not reflect changes in the target group over time and cannot reveal causal relationships. While the current study had sufficient power to detect small to medium effect size, it was underpowered to detect small effect size. Accordingly, future studies with larger sample sizes are needed to confirm the findings of this study. Furthermore, the use of convenience sampling may have introduced selection bias, which limits the generalizability of the findings. The sample was recruited from a single university in Saudi Arabia, which also limits the generalizability. Moreover, students with anxiety disorders were not excluded in this study. Although the study did not collect personal data, social desirability bias could still affect the generalizability of the findings. Nevertheless, the findings are of significance, especially in the context of Saudi Arabia, as no prior studies have examined the association between SAD and parenting styles among nursing students. Furthermore, this study used valid and reliable instruments, which further strengthen its utility.
Nursing implications
The results of this study have important implications for educators and other policymakers at nursing institutions in Saudi Arabia to work toward addressing the mental health needs of nursing students with SAD. These efforts may include early detection screenings, counseling services, and timely referrals to mental health specialists for students with SAD. Nursing educators should undergo specialized training programs to equip them with the knowledge and skills to help them recognize the signs of SAD as well as provide appropriate intervention strategies to support those affected with SAD. One effective strategy that nursing educators should consider is providing regular stress management workshops to help students, especially those with SAD, to cope with academic stress. These workshops can include techniques such as deep breathing, biofeedback, mindfulness, and the emotional freedom technique which can be conducted regularly and in collaboration with psychiatric nurses or other mental health professionals [
33,
34]. Nursing educators can further provide workshops in communication skills to help students build confidence in public speaking and communicate effectively with instructors, healthcare team, and patients. Another effective strategy is a peer mentorship program in which senior students provide guidance and support to first year students [
35]. Additionally, nursing educators should facilitate social skills in students with SAD which can be performed by offering social opportunities such as extracurricular activities and group projects. Nursing educators should cultivate an atmosphere where open communication, particularly regarding mental health challenges, is encouraged. This could be achieved through regular meetings with students in which they can express their feelings and concerns in a comfortable environment. Students with SAD could also benefit from additional training in nursing skills, which may help alleviate their anxiety and improve their confidence. Accordingly, nursing educators should consider providing opportunities for extra training in a safe environment where students feel comfortable in practicing and refining their nursing skills. Moreover, nursing educators and counselors must be aware of the effects of different parenting styles on students’ mental health in order to be able to work closely with the parents of students with SAD. By doing so, they can provide the necessary education to parents and optimize students’ learning experiences.
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.