Introduction
Study setting
Search strategies
Sl.No | Databases | Applied keywords and Boolean operators | |
---|---|---|---|
1. | Google scholar-332 | ||
2. | PubMed-0 | “Braden scale” OR “Pressure sore” OR “Pressure ulcer” OR “Decubitus ulcer” AND “Nurses” OR “Staff Nurses” AND “knowledge” AND “Practice” AND “Health professionals” | |
3. | Science Direct-14 | ||
4. | Cochrane Library-437 | ||
5. | Hinari-322 | ||
6. | Gray Literature-45 |
Eligibility criteria
Outcome measurement
Screening and data extraction
Author | Year | Country | Setting | Duration | Design | Sample | Size | Technique | Scale/Tools | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bassam Alshahrani [15] | 2024 | Australia | Critical care units in three hospitals | May 2021 and April 2022 | Multi-centre observationa l study (Prepost intervention study) | patients | 181 patients | Braden scores | PI prevalence was 60.9% at the outset, with 52.9% hospital- acquired, 37.9% unit- acquired and 23.0% medical device- related. Post- intervention prevalence decreased significantly to 28.7%, including 21.3% hospital- acquired, 14.9% unit- acquired, and 8.5% medical device- related. | |
Talal ALFadhalah [21] | 2024 | Kuwait | Public general hospitals. 54 medical wards | December 2021 to March 2022 | Crosssectional research design | 1,186 patients | 1,186 patients | Braden scale | The mean national prevalence of PI was 17.6% (95% CI: 11.3–23.8). Purely community-acquired PI represent the majority of PI nationally (58.1%). | |
Habtamu Bekele [27] | 2024 | Ethiopia | Specialize d hospitals in the Northwest Amhara Region | June 15 to June 19, 202 | Institutionbased, crosssectional study | 480 patients | 480 patients | Systematic random sampling technique | The Braden RAS includes; sensory perception, moisture, activity, friction /shear, mobility, and nutrition. | A total of 49 pressure ulcers were detected among 480 patients. a prevalence rate of 10.2%, 95% CI (7.7, 12.9). |
Lindsey Stevens [47] | 2024 | New York, United States | Neurosurg ery stepdown unit in a large teaching hospital | January to March 2022 | Prospective, quasiexperimenta l, singlegroup design | 35 Nurses | Braden Scores | Nurses showed increased comprehension after the educational intervention from T1 to T3. | ||
Mohammad Y. N. Saleh [23] | 2023 | Jordan | 3 Jordanian medical settings | A prospective approach | Adult patients | 329 adult patients | Convenien ce sample | Braden scale | Prevalence of MDRPI was 5.01% (15/299) with 41 injuries, 27/41 (65.8%) were skin injuries and 14/41(34.2%) were mucosal. | |
Esraa Mohammed alhussin Abdelhalim [17] | 2023 | Saudi Arabia | King Fahad Hospital | 2019 to 2021 | Retrospectiv e hospitalbased study | Hospital ized patients | 21,400 admitted patients | Braden Scale used for Predicting Pressure Sore Risk. | Significant reduction of HAPUs from 1.97% in 2018 to 1.4% in 2019 and 0.53% in 2020 to 0.14% in 2021. | |
Zhenyu Luo [28] | 2023 | 1 July 2022 and ends on 1 August 2022. | Descriptive observationa l study | 6 PI specialist nurses | Convenien ce sampling. | MDRPI and Braden Scale sessions | The mean referral time among participants was 2.26 ± 0.26 h, the mean Braden score was 15.32 ± 2.06, 53.46% (n = 54) of participants were conscious, 73.26% (n = 74) were in the supine position, 23.76% (n = 24) were in the semirecumbent position, and only 3 (2.9%) were in the lateral position. | |||
Fatma Mohamed Elesawy [33] | 2023 | Egypt | South Valley University Hospital. | Quasiexperimenta l design | 36 nurses and 8 patients | Structured interview questionnaire; nurses’ pressure ulcer preventive practices observational checklist, comprehensive skin assessment tool, and Braden Scale | Nurses’ knowledge and practices were significantly improved towards pressure ulcer prevention after program implementation | |||
Hanaa E. Elsayad [36] | 2023 | Egypt | Orthopaed ic departme nt at Menoufia University Hospital. | Quasiexperimental l design, | Consecu tive sample of 118 immobil ized adult patients of both genders. | Instrument I: Structured Interview questionnaire, Instrument II: Comprehensive skin assessment observation checklist, Instrument III: Braden Risk Assessment Scale. | It was described that 49.2% of the study group and 35.6% of the control group was in the category of age between 50 < 60 years old and around half of both study and control groups (50.8% and 54.2% respectively) was male. | |||
Rekha Pant [41] | 2023 | India | Teer thanker Mahaveer University Hospital of Moradaba d. | 80 staff nurses | Convenien ce sampling method. | Out of 80 samples, 49 (61.2%) of staff nurses had inadequate knowledge, 25 (31.3%) were had moderate knowledge & 6 (7.5%) were had adequate knowledge with respect to pre-test attitude within staff nurses, among 80 samples, 53(66.3%) were having unfavourable attitude and 27(33.7%) were having favourable attitude. | ||||
Shenda Maulina Wulandari [43] | 2023 | Correlative descriptive method with a cross- sectional approach | 46 responden ts | Total sampling technique | Braden Q scale, Nurses knowledge assessment tool | The results of this study showed that more than half of the nurses had sufficient knowledge both regarding the Braden Q scale. | ||||
Tuba Sengul [26] | 2022 | Turkey | Private hospital administer ed by a foundatio n in Istanbul. | August 1 and December 31, 2021 | Cross-sectional and descriptive study | COVID- 19 patients | 345 patients | Braden Risk Assessment Scale | The mean of Braden scale total score of the patients with PI was found to be 16.50 ± 3.83 and 20.05 ± 3.07 for those without PI. | |
Gulay Yazıcı [24] | 2022 | Turkey | State university hospital in Ankara | 17–23 December, 2018. | Descriptive study | Patients | 23 patients | Braden score/scale | The prevalence of Pressure Injuries in the patients followed up within the scope of this study was 17.4%; 85.71% of them were hospital-acquired injuries; 57.14% of them were stage 1; and 71.4% of them were related to medical devices. | |
Lei Ding [18] | 2022 | China | Four medical centres in China. | January 2014 to December 2018 | Mixed case– control study. | Patients | 1977 patients | Braden scale | Age, sex, Braden rating and diabetes were found to be independent risk factors for CAPressure Injuries, as evidenced by the corresponding OR and 95% CI values of 1.031 (1.026 to 1.036), 0.810 (0.698 to 0.941), 1.235 (1.167 to 1.307) and 2.059 (1.332 to 3.184), respectively. Purely CAPressure Injuries represent the majority of PI nationally (58.1%). | |
Busra İpek [48] | 2022 | Turkey | Cross-sectional, descriptive, prospective design. | Purposive sampling method | Sociodemographic and Clinical Characteristics Form and 3 S- IRAS for PI and Braden Scale | IAPI occurred in 18.0% of participants. Although the risk of PI was higher in women, those with chronic disease, those with major surgery, and those with chronic disease, this risk was weaker. | ||||
Ruth Alexandra Castiblanco -Montanez [31] | 2022 | Descriptive cross-sectional study | 50 medical records | Patients who were hospitalize d | Braden scale. | The most frequent type of skin lesion is pressure ulcers with 24 cases (40%), the most reported anatomical site of injury was the sacral region with 40% followed by 30% with more than one location. | ||||
Kawther Badry Mobed [32] | 2022 | Egypt | Trauma and emergenc y ddepartm ent at Assiut university Hospital | Quasi experimental research design | 33 male and 27 female | Sixty | Skin assessment observation check list and Braden scale | Skin integrity care bundle had a positive effect in preventing the development of pressure ulcer among studied patients in the study group where the majority (90%) of the patients showed no pressure ulcers or no sign of pressure ulcer after application of the nursing intervention | ||
Gehan Abd Elfattah Atia Elasrag [34] | 2022 | Eygpt | ICU at Menoufia University Hospital | Experimental research design | Control and study group 50 patients | Purposive sample | 1st tool: Predesigned questionnaire which contained two parts, 2nd tool: Braden Scale and 3rd tool: EPUAP and 4th tool: PUSH | Presented that 56% and 18% of control group had moderate risk and high risk for pressure ulcer, while 54% and 20% of study group had moderate and high risk. | ||
Doaa Mohamed Mahmoud [38] | 2022 | Eygpt | Benha University Hospital’s orthopaed ic unit | Quasiexperimental l research approach (study and control groups). | 60 adult patients | Purposive sample | Comprehensive skin assessment sheet, Braden Risk Assessment Scale. | There was a statistically significant variation in patients’ Outcomes regarding pressure ulcers following application of evidencebased practises guidelines between the study and control groups. | ||
Ebtsam Saad Soliman [16] | 2022 | Eygpt | Mansoura University and emergenc y hospitals. | Quasiexperimental l, pre-test and posttest intervention study design | 50 nurses,8 0 patients | Convenien t sample | Interview questionnaire, Observational check list for nurses’ practice, Braden Scale, Patient’s assessment questionnaire | Total knowledge level and total practice level mean scores immediate post and after one month follow up of the program implementation were higher statistically significant than preprogram. | ||
E.S.S. Saad [40] | 2022 | Eygpt | Orthopedi c departme nt of Benha University Hospital. | Convenient sample | 50 nurses, 80 patients | I-Interview Questionnaire, II- Observational check list for nurses’ practice, III-Braden Scale & Inpatient’s’ Assessment questi onnaire | This study showed only 22%, 20 of studied nurses had good level of total (knowledge, practice) about pressure ulcer at pre implementation of program. | |||
Fitri Anita [42] | 2022 | Quasiexperimental l method with pre and post-test | 17 patients for each group (interve ntion and control). | Assessment of the risk of PI using the Braden scale, and monitoring of changes in position using the observation sheet. | Data analysis showed that the combination of an air cushion and a 30º position effectively reduced the risk of injury p-value of 0.035 (< 0.05). | |||||
Masoud Hatefi [44] | 2022 | Iran | Cross-sectional descriptive study | Sample size = 220 | Demographic profile form and the Braden Scale for Predicting PU Risks. | It showed most of the patients achieved scores in poor and low risk status. Also, the overall score for risk of Pus was low, moderate, and high, and very high in 28 (12.7%), 81 (36.7%), 105 (47.7%), and 6 (2.7%) of cases, respectively. | ||||
Fatma Magdi Ibrahim [45] | 2022 | UAE | ICUs of the General Mansoura Hospital, Specialize d Medical Hospital, and Emergenc y Hospital in Dakhalia governora te | Quasiexperimental l study | 69 nurses. | Braden Scale and a 2-part structured interview schedule sheet. | Following the educational film, the nurse’s practice and knowledge increased, plus there was an enhancement in wound healing of pressure ulcers for older adults. | |||
Amany El- berdan[46] | 2022 | Egypt | Intensive Care Unit | Quasiexperimental l study | 51 nurses and 80 patients | Convenien t sample | Structured interview sheet, observational checklist, Braden Scale | The study revealed that nurses’ knowledge and practices significantly improved towards pressure ulcers post program implementation when compared to pre-program (with P value less than 0.05) | ||
Asmaa Nasr ELdin Mosbeh[49] | 2022 | Egypt | NICUs at El- Fayoum University Hospital and El- Fayoum Public Hospital. | A descriptive design | 80 nurses | Convenien t sample | Predesigned Questionnaire format to assess characteristics of the studied nurses and their knowledge regarding skin care and Braden Q Scale. | The mean experience years 7.3 ± 1, more than one-third of them had good total knowledge and more than half of them had incompetent total practice about skin care in NICU. | ||
Heba Mohamed Tawfik [19] | 2021 | Egypt | Ain Shams University Hospitals and in Suez Canal University Hospitals. | Case control study | Elderly male and female patients | 100 | Purposive sample | Checklist and Braden scale | Braden scale was highly sensitive for the occurrence of pressure ulcers (cutoff point ≤ 17) with 77.4% positive predictive value and 97.3% negative predictive value. | |
Despina Georgieva [29] | 2021 | May and November 2019. | 120 hospitali zed patients | 120 hospitalize d patients | Braden scale | 50, 83% of the respondents have got quite a risk of decubitus wounds occurring, 26,67% are at great risk, and 14,17% are at moderate risk. Only 8, 33% of all patients tested are at light risk. | ||||
Samia Gaballah [25] | 2021 | Egypt | General hospitals, in Ismailia City | Quasiexperimenta l control group using pre-post | Nurses and patients | Thirty nurses and fifty Patients | Nurse ’s demographic data sheet, PI knowledge questionnaire, PI care observational checklist, Patient’s demographic and medical profile data sheet, The Braden Scale, and Patients’ PI wound healing outcomes tool | The study revealed that nurses’ knowledge and practices, were significantly improved towards PI care post program implementation when compared to pre-program. | ||
Mona Mohamed Ibrahim [35] | 2021 | Egypt | 8 orthopaed ic departme nts of one of the governme ntal hospitals in Egypt | Quasi experimenta l research design | Patients in each interven tion and control groups). | 80 (40 patients in each interventi on and control groups). | Purposefu l sample technique | Patient Assessment Tool, Braden Risk Assessment Scale | Stated that, 52.5% of the patients who were cared through implementing care bundle elements did not develop pressure ulcers after four days | |
Vanessa Leal de Lima de Moura [50] | 2021 | Brazil. | November 2020 | 27 nurses | Braden scale application | There was a prevalence of participation of nurses working in ICU (n = 8;29.63%), and in hospitalization units (n = 5; 18.52%). | ||||
Edward, M.I. [51] | 2021 | Nigeria | University of Medical Sciences Teaching Hospital, Akure and University of Medical Sciences Teaching Hospital, Ondo. | Crosssectional descriptive nonexperimenta l design | Braden scale in predicting PI risk, questionnaire | Results showed that the majority of nurses have good knowledge of Braden scale but had poor perception towards its use in predicting pressure ulcer. | ||||
Pramila Baral [30] | 2020 | Nepal Medical College Teaching Hospital | August 2019 to January 2020. | Crosssectional descriptive study | 272 patients | 272 patients | ||||
Na, Hyung-Ju [20] | 2020 | Mediumsized hospital, located in Seoul | December 18, 2017 to February 28, 2018 | Patients | 100 | Randamiz ation | Braden scale for risk assessment and the 6-stage pressure ulcer classification system | Total score on the Braden scale, the ICC was 0.85 and the Po was 0.29. | ||
AAbiru Neme [22] | 2020 | Ethiopia | Public hospitals | March13-April 12, 2017 | Institution based cross sectional study design | Hospital ized patients | 356 subjects | Multistage sampling technique | Braden scale | A total of 56 Patients were Develop pressure ulcer from 356 admitted in Public Hospitals, with the prevalence rate of 15.7%; from which 6 (1.7%), 34 (9.6%), and 16 (4.5%) were Medical Device Related Pressure Ulcers and Routine Pressure Ulcers. |
Mona Mohamed Ibrahim [35] | 2020 | Egypt | Neurologi cal units (A and B) at Mansoura University Hospital. | Quasiexperimenta l stud prepost-test assessment | 40 nurses | Convenien ce sample | Interview Questionnaire Sheet, The PZPUKT, Facility Assessment Checklist, Moore & Price attitude scale, Sociodemographic and medical clinical base line data for patients and Braden Scale. | The result revealed a positive association between pressure ulcer educational protocol prevention and nurses’ knowledge, attitude and practice to ward pressure ulcer prevention. | ||
Manal Tharwat AbouZaid [39] | 2020 | Egypt | Mansoura University and emergenc y hospitals. | Nurses and patients | 55 nurses, 207 patients | A structured interview, wound care observational checklist, Braden scale, wound assessment tool. | A statistically significant improvement in nurses’ practice regarding wound care after implementing wound care protocol with (Pvalue = 0.014 and 0.000 respectively). |