Background
Ontology and terminology
-
AI is about machines that perform pure calculations. They are not based on logical thinking and merely imitate human characteristics [6].
Relevance and appliance in nursing context
Research about nurses perceptions
AI Categories | Subitems | Sources |
---|---|---|
Knowledge | Uncertainties in terminology and lack of AI knowledge | |
Lack of experience & application in nursing | ||
Attitudes | AI enhances nursing outcomes & reliefs staffa | |
AI increases efficiency & reduces costsa | ||
AI is available, user-friendly & easy to usea | ||
AI changes organizations & workflowsb | ||
AI changes leadershipb | ||
AI influences nursing rolesb | ||
AI isn’t capable enough to replace human interactionc | ||
AI as frightening threat & mistrustc | ||
Unawareness of advantages & applicationsc | ||
Worries about patient relationship & safetyc | ||
Barriers | Anxiety of job loss and full automation | |
Missing education and sensitization | ||
Lack of data and interfaces to train AI | ||
Errors, unexpected results and AI trustworthiness | ||
Regulatory Frameworks and Data Protection | ||
Facilitators | Positive Outcomes increases intention to use AI | |
Proactive define AI & advocate for patients | ||
Empathetic & personalised AI applications | ||
Application in health monitoring, documentation, communication, & clinical decisions support | ||
Training & Information about AI | ||
IT clinicians & technical infrastructure | ||
Further Research | AI applications & outcomes, esp. relief of nurses | |
Nursing perspective, acceptance, nursing role | ||
Acceptance & user-centered design | ||
Ethical, social & legal implications | ||
Limitations: response, study sample & lab settings |
Methods
Objective and research question
Study instrument
Data collection
Data analysis
Categories | Subcategories | Description for Items |
---|---|---|
Knowledge and definition of AI | Computer-based | AI as a hardware-based solution |
Programming-based | AI as a (text-generating) program | |
Input-/information-/data-based | AI as system relying on data | |
Learning | AI as a developing thing | |
Decision-making | AI as a decision helper | |
Human-like | AI as a natural, human-like interaction | |
Robot-like | AI as a machine, a robot | |
Naming AI providers and tools | AI as e.g. ChatGPT or Mindjourney | |
Opportunities and perceived benefits | Support and relief in patient care | AI as helper for patient care tasks |
Knowledge acquisition | AI as a tool to find information | |
Helping in administrative tasks | AI as writing/ documentation support | |
Assistance systems | AI with robots as assistance | |
Anxiety and disadvantages | Fears of job replacement | AI as threat for nursing jobs |
Impersonally | AI as a threat to social relationships | |
Mistakes | AI as error source due to incomplete data | |
Insufficient Outcome | AI as not comprehensive to human output | |
Costs and implementation efforts | AI as expensive in implementing | |
Facilitators and future needs | Sensitization | AI information is necessary for nurses |
Refinancing | AI usage in health facilities needs financing | |
Data | AI usage in health facilities needs data | |
User-friendliness | AI should be easy to use and simple | |
Use cases | AI should be helpful and practicable |
Results
Demographic data
Variable | Category | n ( %) |
---|---|---|
Gender | Female | 77 (67.5 %) |
Male | 37 (32.5 %) | |
Diverse | 0 (00.0 %) | |
Age group | under 21 years | 1 (00.9 %) |
21-30 years | 23 (20.4 %) | |
31-40 years | 33 (29.2 %) | |
41-50 years | 24 (21.2 %) | |
51-60 years | 26 (23.0 %) | |
over 60 years | 6 (05.3 %) | |
Facility form | Inpatient long-term care | 45 (39,8 %) |
Outpatient care | 18 (15,9 %) | |
Nursing (hospital/clinic) | 21 (18.6 %) | |
Other | 29 (25,7 %) | |
Education level | Secondary school diploma | 21 (18.6 %) |
Higher School or specialized secondary school | 16 (14.2 %) | |
Completed vocational training | 33 (29.2 %) | |
University degree (at least Bachelor’s degree) | 35 (31.0 %) | |
Other | 6 (05.3 %) |
Understanding of AI
Variable | Category | n ( %) |
---|---|---|
How much do you know about AI? | I would describe myself as an AI expert.a | 2 (01.8 %) |
I can explain well what is meant by it.a | 26 (23.4 %) | |
I know roughly what is meant by it.b | 67 (60.4 %) | |
I know the term, but I don’t know what it means.b | 14 (12.6 %) | |
I have not heard the term before.b | 2 (01.8 %) |
Furthermore, nurses recognize that AI is not a ready-to-use solution but requires data processing and preparation (Text 1, para. 11). Nurses understand the critical role of data quality in shaping AI as a decision-making instrument (Text 1, para. 55).‘AI is a machine with practices to perform and learn from data’ (Text 1, para. 34)‘AI is programmed by humans and is intended to be used in multiple domains to make decisions, perform actions, and perform everyday human tasks within its programming and to identify and solve problems.’ (Text 1, para. 36)‘AI means using robots which can react to movements or speech.’ (Text 1, para. 83)‘AI [...] can act similarly to a human, e.g., write text, act human, etc.’ (Text 1, para. 31)‘AI is a machine’s ability to imitate human abilities.’ (Text 1, para. 72)‘AI can decide and learn alone, considering markers taught to it.’ (Text 1, para. 15)
Use-cases and applications
Variable | Category | n ( %) |
---|---|---|
Which application areasa of AI in nursing do you know? | Patient monitoring (e.g. vital signs, sleep) | 49 (55.7 %) |
Route planning | 42 (47.7 %) | |
Nursing documentation | 38 (43.2 %) | |
Patient care prediction (e.g. fall detection) | 34 (38.6 %) | |
Making nursing diagnoses | 28 (31.8 %) | |
Wound management | 19 (21.6 %) |
Opportunities and positive AI perception
Variable | Category | n ( %) |
---|---|---|
Do you see AI in nursing more as an opportunity or more as a threat? | Exclusively as an opportunitya | 14 (13.7 %) |
Rather as an opportunitya | 53 (52.0 %) | |
Rather as a dangerb | 13 (12.7 %) | |
Exclusively as a dangerb | 1 (01.0 %) | |
I do not know, I cannot judge | 22 (21.6 %) |
Moreover, nurses appreciate the role of AI in knowledge acquisition, including AI to answer questions, provide guidance, and aid in documentation. AI’s predictive capabilities are beneficial, allowing for early detection of care needs and risks, such as sepsis from care and laboratory parameters (Text 4, para. 170, Text 3, para. 152).’In the area of AI, we are at the beginning of the changes in nursing.’ (Text 4, para. 171)’AI has been part of our everyday lives for a long time. Whether as Siri [or] Alexa, AI tries to make everyday things easier or improve them. However, these are only minor peripheral areas, AI can recognize feelings and record vital parameters.’ (Text 1, para. 42)’AI means to optimize and support work and relieve employees.’ (Text 1, para. 74)
Threats and negative AI perception
’I am afraid of AI stupidity, a system that delivers results after training that is not comprehensible because the sources are missing.’ (Text 1, para. 23)’AI threatens our jobs and makes care even more impersonal.’ (Text 1, para. 29)’It is also a question of refinancing. Unfortunately, it is often not possible for cost reasons to implement meaningful innovations or purchase them.’ (Text 4, para. 171)
Profiteers and beneficial user groups
Variable | Category | n ( %) |
---|---|---|
Which group of people benefits most from the use of AI? | Administration and management staff | 47 (49.5 %) |
Nursing and support staff | 24 (25.3 %) | |
Patients in need of care | 17 (17.9 %) | |
Social services and support | 7 (07.4 %) |
Needs for further AI implementation
As the quotes also conduct, user experience is another critical factor. AI solutions must be user-friendly, easy to use, and time-saving (Text 4, para. 161). Furthermore, the quotes show that AI solutions are still not satisfying enough, leading to the potential for improvements. Lastly, considerations regarding the costs and effort required for implementation should not be overlooked (Text 4, para. 165).’AI [...] must be fed with input to get a corresponding output.’ (Text 1, para. 11)’All groups of people will benefit only if they actively embrace this change. This is likely the greatest challenge, along with sensible refinancing.’ (Text 4, para. 165)’AI should be regulated, no one should lose her job through AI, and the relationship with patients must be preserved.’ (Text 4, para. 159)’Humans should be able to access and "reprogram" at any time.’ (Text 4, para. 164)’AI in route planning currently depends on too many parameters to work properly. AI should always be developed to provide maximum support to the nurse.’ (Text 4, para. 167)