Introduction
Material and methods
Design
Search methods
Inclusion and exclusion criteria
Data extraction
Quality appraisal
Author, Published Year | JBI Critical Appraisal Tool | Study Design |
---|---|---|
Raabe et al. 2015 [22] | 84,6% (11/13) | RCT |
Pyne et al. 2019 [23] | 92,3% (12/13) | RCT |
Daneshvar et al. 2022 [24] | 76,9% (10/13) | RCT |
Rajan et al. 2022 [25] | 76,9% (10/13) | RCT |
Belleville et al. 2018 [26] | 92,3% (12/13) | RCT |
Gilmore et al. 2021 [27] | 84,6% (11/13) | RCT |
Jimenez Peregrina et al. 2020 [28] | 84,6% (11/13) | RCT |
Andersen et al. 2021 [29] | 92,3% (12/13) | RCT |
Orang et al. 2018 [30] | 76,9% (10/13) | RCT |
Pearson et al. 2019 [31] | 76,9% (10/13) | RCT |
O’Cleirigh et al. 2019 [32] | 84,6% (11/13) | RCT |
Murray et al. 2018 [33] | 92,3% (12/13) | RCT |
Data analysis
Results
The explanation of each nursing intervention method | |||
---|---|---|---|
Authors and Year | Purpose | Method | Result |
Improve Skill Interventions | |||
Raabe et al. 2015 [22] | Reduce negative effect of traumatic experience | STAIR is an intervention that is carried out online. Participants carry out activities for 12 weeks (30 min/session by telephone). In the first session, participants were given training on problem solving. Then the participants were given time to consult with a therapist who is a mental nurse to control the trauma experienced by victims of sexual violence | there was a decrease in PTSD symptoms in victims of sexual violence |
Pyne et al. 2019 [23] | Improve resilience and reduce PTSD on victims of sexual violence | Heart Rate Variability and Cognitive Bias Feedback Interventions are cognitive capacity building activities to overcome the effects of trauma. Participants take part in activities for 16 weeks (1 h/session). Participants were given psychoeducation about trauma management which can be done independently for 40 min. Then participants will conduct training sessions to improve empathy, problem solving, and emotional management | Significant decrease in PTSD symptoms in victims of sexual violence |
Rajan et al. 2022 [25] | reduction of symptoms of PTSD in individuals with PTSD | Modified Lifespan Integration is an intervention carried out over 8 sessions. Each session is given time for 90–140 min. The intervention was only carried out by female therapists because most perpetrators of sexual violence were men, which traumatized victims. The sessions are audio-recorded and stored to allow monitoring of therapist adherence to treatment protocols. Participants will be trained to express their feelings and then be directed to make several solutions to the problem of trauma due to sexual violence | effective results in reducing PTSD symptoms |
Orang et al. 2018 [30] | Effect intervention on psychological wellbeing and PTSD | Narrative exposure therapy is an intervention in the form of consultation to seek help from resources such as family of origin, police or lawyers, improvement of coping skills and safety planning, and human rights education. Participants intervened for 10 sessions with a duration of 120–150 min/session. The first session began with a discussion between participants and nurses about the sexual violence they experienced, to make sure the patient was ready to face traumatic events in the past. Then participants took part in a psychoeducational session about PTSD symptoms and an explanation of goals and interventions. Then the participants attended counseling with psychiatric nurses and psychologists to resolve the trauma they experienced | This intervention has been shown to reduce PTSD symptoms in victims of sexual violence |
Gilmore et al. 2021 [27] | Reduce symptoms of PTSD | Video-Based Intervention features a female narrator who provides information to prevent emotional problems in victims of sexual violence. The videos provide instructions for implementing self-help exercises for dealing with trauma, methods for recognizing and stopping inappropriate coping, and strategies for engaging in activities that reduce PTSD. The intervention was carried out for 12 weeks for 8 sessions | This intervention can effectively reduce PTSD symptoms in victims of sexual violence |
Relaxation interventions | |||
Jimenez Peregrina et al. 2020 [28] | Improve resilience and reduce symptoms of PTSD | Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) therapy is a comprehensive patient-centered psychotherapy approach over 8 sessions(Jimenez Peregrina et al., 2020). EMDR therapy is guided by nurses to control the emotions felt when remembering traumatic experiences. Participants were asked by the nurse to remember the traumatic experiences experienced by the participants. Then participants perform eye movements to address the memory you are targeting. During this session, participants were asked to focus on negative thoughts, memories, or images they were experiencing | The results of this intervention show a decrease in PTSD symptoms in victims of sexual violence |
Andersen et al. 2021 [29] | Effect on psychological and somatic symptoms, and reduce PTSD | The Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) intervention is a therapy that is carried out for 8 weeks (2 h/week). Activities undertaken include experiential exercises on non-judgmental mindfulness of breathing, body scanning, and yoga. Nurses play a role in training participants to relax and guide the course of mindfulness therapy | This intervention has been proven to reduce symptoms of trauma experienced by participants who experienced sexual violence |
Cognitive behavior therapy | |||
Belleville et al. 2018 [26] | Reduction of symptoms of PTSD | Imagery Rehearsal Therapy and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy is carried out for 15 sessions/15 weeks. The activities carried out in this intervention are psychoeducation, counseling, and skills training such as empathy, problem solving, self-management, and emotional management. The nurse acts as an educator to increase participants' understanding of trauma, its causes and effects. Nurses also act as trainers to improve participants' skills in overcoming PTSD | This study shows that the intervention is proven to be effective in reducing PTSD symptoms |
Daneshvar et al. 2022 [24] | Improve meaning-in-life and reduce PTSD | Group-based Compassion-focused Therapy is an intervention that is carried out offline in 8 sessions (1 h/session). Activities in this intervention started with psychoeducation about trauma and the effects of trauma. Then participants take part in activities to train empathy, train sympathy, practice forgiveness, practice acceptance of unpleasant events, train to develop feelings of worth and transcendence: Helping individuals to develop feelings of self-esteem so they can deal with conditions effectively and efficiently, train commitment to self themselves, and practice and review previously taught skills. Nurses act as facilitators and educators in the training process carried out | This study shows that there is an improvement in mental health and a decrease in PTSD symptoms |
Pearson et al. 2019 [31] | Effect intervention on PTSD symptoms, high-risk sexual behavior, and substance use | Cognitive Processing Therapy was carried out in 13 sessions for 16 weeks. Activities carried out are identifying the worst trauma and reviewing symptoms of trauma, overcoming "unhelpful" mindsets, "balancing" thoughts and feelings, increasing trust, power and control, respect, and caring. The nurse acts as a facilitator to guide the intervention process | This intervention is proven to reduce the symptoms of trauma experienced by participants |
O’Cleirigh et al. 2019 [32] | Effect on PTSD symptoms | Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Trauma and Self Care focuses on counseling to reduce the impact of sexual violence experienced by participants. The intervention was carried out for 8 sessions for 16 weeks. Participants were given psychoeducation about the effects of trauma, normalizing symptoms of post-traumatic stress, and reviewing the adaptive coping strategies used. Then participants were given cognitive therapy strategies, behavioral techniques, and counselling. Then participants were given lessons on identifying cognitive distortions (eg self-blame, guilt), and strategies for challenging and changing unrealistic beliefs | Effectively reduce symptoms of PTSD on victims of sexual violence |
Murray et al. 2018 [33] | Effect on PTSD and anxiety | Cognitive processing therapy (CPT) is psychotherapy to reduce mental health problems in victims of sexual violence. Treatment occurred over 12 sessions (with a duration of 2 h/session). The activities carried out were psychoeducation about PTSD and how to deal with trauma due to sexual violence, then participants were given training in empathy and problem solving skills to discuss how to deal with the effects of PTSD. This study shows that CPT can reduce PTSD symptoms | Significantly reduce symptoms PTSD and anxiety |